CreatorTEDx Talks
SpeakerRana Kordahi
EventTEDxCQU
Sourceyoutu.be/lKedDUV8MO0
Processed2026-06-05
Summary

Rana Kordahi opens with two vivid stories from her childhood in wartime Beirut -- one where her father's poor negotiation skills got the family turned away at a border, and another where his calm rapport-building talked a gunman out of pulling the trigger. These bookends frame the central argument: selling is not a job function but a fundamental life skill that shapes outcomes at every level of human interaction.

Kordahi draws a sharp distinction between pushy salespeople, who lead with product and pressure, and consultative salespeople, who lead with questions and genuine curiosity about the other person's situation. The consultative model, she argues, mirrors the best practices of psychology -- specifically the technique of asking questions that lead people to their own conclusions rather than being told what to do or think.

She identifies three attributes that underpin success in sales and in life: courage to face rejection and keep going, patience to let compounding results build over time, and a relentless work ethic that ignores the myth of overnight success. Woven throughout is the practical message that confidence, rapport, persuasion, and understanding what others value are all learnable skills -- and that learning them changes everything.

Key Points
Quotable Moments

Quotable moments are auto-generated from the transcript. Speaker attribution and quote accuracy should be verified against the original source before republishing or sharing.

Rana Kordahi
"It doesn't matter how talented you are, how smart, how PhD'd up you are, or technically brilliant you are -- if you don't know how to sell and communicate, you're not gonna get very far in life."
Why it works: Blunt, inclusive, and hard to argue with. It frames communication not as a nice-to-have but as the prerequisite to every other capability a person has.
Rana Kordahi
"People buy people -- they buy into you before they're going to buy your products and services."
Why it works: The repetition of "buy" shifts the metaphor from commercial transaction to human trust. It reframes rapport as a fundamental currency, not a tactic.
Rana Kordahi
"The pushy salesperson walks into a networking situation and thinks, I wonder who I can take from here today. The consultative salesperson thinks, I wonder who I can help here today."
Why it works: The parallel structure makes the contrast immediate and memorable. It works as a personal values test anyone can apply before walking into any room.
Rana Kordahi
"You plant seeds today, they'll grow tomorrow -- but many people plant seeds, stop being patient, and give up."
Why it works: The agricultural metaphor is simple and universal. It turns abstract advice about patience into something visceral and easy to carry forward.
Concepts and Ideas
Core Framework

Selling as a Universal Human Skill

Kordahi argues that selling is not confined to commercial roles -- it is the mechanism by which any person advances any idea, relationship, or goal. The moment you try to change someone's mind, win a job, negotiate a conflict, or influence a decision, you are selling. Refusing to engage with that word, she suggests, leaves people less equipped for the reality they already live in.

Pushy vs. Consultative Salespeople

The pushy salesperson leads with product, talks more than they listen, and applies pressure to force a decision. The consultative salesperson leads with curiosity, asks questions to understand the other person's situation, and works to solve problems rather than move inventory. The consultative approach is durable; the pushy approach burns relationships.

ABC Reframed: Always Be Connecting

The classic sales acronym "Always Be Closing" represents the pushy model's obsession with the transaction. Kordahi reframes it as "Always Be Connecting" -- a shift from extraction to relationship-building that, paradoxically, produces better long-term commercial outcomes as well as better human interactions.

Practical Principles

Confidence as the Foundational Variable

Santiago, a high school dropout with poor English, outsold the well-credentialed James because he had unshakable confidence in himself and his abilities. The point is not that credentials don't matter -- it is that soft confidence in the face of rejection is the rarer and more decisive asset. Most people have the skills; they lack the self-belief to use them consistently.

People Buy People

Rapport precedes every sale, every agreement, every shift in another person's thinking. Kordahi traces this principle from face-to-face sales through social media: every post, comment, and online behavior builds or erodes virtual rapport with an audience that forms opinions before ever speaking to you directly. The principle travels across all channels.

The Three Rules of Persuasion

People are more likely to move when they are the ones talking. People are more likely to act when the solution feels like their own idea. And no persuasion attempt should begin with a pitch before the other person has expressed what they want or need. These three rules are derived from behavioral psychology research and run contrary to how most people attempt to convince others.

Questions Over Prescriptions

Kordahi draws a direct parallel between good sales technique and good psychotherapy: neither the therapist nor the consultative salesperson tells the other person what to do. Both ask questions that create a space for the person to think out loud, reach their own insight, and take action that feels self-authored. Autonomy in decision-making is not just a preference -- research shows people are far more likely to follow through on conclusions they reached themselves.

Selling to the Other Person's Values, Not Your Own

Maggie the travel agent lost Tony because she described a vacation through her own lens -- beaches, cocktails, restaurant food -- none of which mattered to Tony, who needed a gym, a kitchen, and fast Wi-Fi. The failure was not about product knowledge; it was a failure to ask discovery questions and then communicate in the language of what the other person actually cares about. This applies to every persuasive situation, including parenting, management, and leadership.

Mindset and Performance

Visualization as a Performance Tool

A sales mentor introduced Kordahi to a visualization practice -- closing her eyes, feeling the rapport, seeing the signed contract, feeling the number she would hit -- before she ever walked into a meeting. She was skeptical but tried it, and results followed within a week. She subsequently applied the same practice to health, fitness, business, and relationships. The technique is not mystical; it is a standard component of elite athletic and performance psychology.

Mindset as the Primary Objection

When Kordahi was struggling in a sales role and reading books on overcoming objections, her mentor told her to throw the book away. The real objection, he said, was her own mindset -- not the customer's hesitations. This reframe applies broadly: when results are poor, the first variable to examine is not technique or product, but the internal state the person brings to the work.

The Three Pillars of Sustained Success

Courage

Courage in this context means going out, getting rejected, and continuing anyway. It is not the absence of fear of rejection but the decision to act despite it. Without this, all other skills remain theoretical because they never get repeated practice against real conditions.

Patience and the Compound Effect

Seeds planted today grow tomorrow -- but not today. Most people quit before compounding has had time to work. The compound effect is the mechanism by which consistent small actions produce large results over time, and patience is the human quality required to stay in the game long enough to experience it.

Relentless Work Ethic

Kordahi is explicit: overnight success courses are fiction. The results she describes in her own life and career came from sustained, hard work over two decades. Work ethic is not glamorous to talk about, but it is the substrate under every other principle she discusses.

Implementation

Implementation steps are auto-generated from the transcript content and are provided for informational purposes only. They do not constitute professional advice of any kind. Always consult a qualified professional before acting on any information presented here.

01

Accept That You Are Already in Sales

Write down three situations from the past week where you tried to change someone's mind, win agreement, or get someone to act differently. Label each one for what it was: a sale. This exercise strips the taboo from the word and starts building honest self-awareness about where your communication skills are actually tested. Once you recognize the selling that already happens in your life, you can start improving it intentionally.

02

Audit Your Online Rapport

Scroll through your last 30 social media posts or comments as if you were a stranger encountering you for the first time. Ask what impression someone would form. Kordahi learned this the hard way by spreading a message aggressively and watching people tune out. Virtual rapport is built or broken the same way face-to-face rapport is -- through tone, consistency, and whether people feel you are trying to give or take. Adjust your online presence accordingly.

03

Replace Pitching with Discovery Questions

In your next significant persuasive conversation -- a client call, a negotiation, a discussion with a colleague -- commit to asking at least three discovery questions before you say anything about your position or solution. Model the psychologist pattern: what would you most like to change, how is the current situation affecting you, and what action do you think you might need to take. Let the other person do the thinking. You will find they arrive at your conclusion faster than if you had stated it directly.

04

Learn What the Other Person Actually Values

Before any important conversation where you need to persuade someone, write down what you think they care most about -- not what you would care about in their position. Then ask a question that lets them confirm or correct your assumption. Maggie's mistake with Tony was not ignorance; it was assumption. The fix is simple: ask before you recommend. Build a habit of separating your values from the other person's before you open your mouth.

05

Build a Daily Visualization Practice

Before a high-stakes interaction -- a sales call, a pitch, a negotiation, a difficult conversation -- spend three to five minutes in quiet visualization. See yourself building genuine rapport, asking good questions, and reaching a successful outcome for both parties. Feel it as real rather than rehearsing it as a script. Kordahi used this practice consistently after initial skepticism and reported measurable results within days. It is worth trying as a low-cost, high-upside experiment.

06

Study Your Confidence, Not Just Your Craft

Santiago did not win because of superior product knowledge or presentation skills. He won because his self-confidence did not falter under rejection. Identify one area where you know the material but hold back because of self-doubt. Practice that skill in lower-stakes contexts specifically to build the repetitions needed to produce unshakable confidence. Confidence is not a trait -- it is a skill built through action under pressure.

07

Measure Rejection Tolerance, Not Just Results

Courage, as Kordahi defines it, is continuing to act after rejection without letting that rejection erode confidence. Track how many times you put yourself forward in a given week -- in pitches, applications, ideas raised in meetings, introductions made. The ratio of action to outcome is less important than maintaining the action rate. People who get results in sales and life are almost always the ones who simply stayed in the game longer than everyone else.

08

Commit to a Compound Effort Window

Pick one area where you want results -- a business development effort, a content strategy, a personal skill -- and commit to a minimum of six months of consistent daily or weekly effort before making any judgment about whether it is working. Kordahi's mentor used the seed metaphor because it captures what most people get wrong: they plant and then dig the seed back up to check on it. Patience is a decision made in advance, not a feeling you wait for.

Full Transcript

This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors in speaker attribution, transcription accuracy, or formatting. Long transcripts may be truncated due to processing limits. Confirm accuracy and completeness against the original source before referencing or republishing.

[00:07]
Rana Kordahi
It was hailing bombs in Beirut, Lebanon, and as a family -- my father, my mom, my sisters, my two younger sisters -- we escaped by boat to Cyprus. I was about nine years old, and I vaguely remember my father arguing with the border patrol man to let us through. He was not listening, he was being aggressive, and the border patrol man was not happy with my father. So you can say that the border patrol man sent us back into Lebanon, Beirut, into the war zone. Now, what did my father lack in this situation? He lacked rapport-building skills, he lacked listening skills, and most importantly he lacked the right mindset to stay calm under pressure. But another time my father did a brilliant job at selling. We were stuck in traffic and I was about eight years old. Now imagine a 1980s summer day in Beirut -- there are old forts everywhere, Mercedes-Benzes, smoke, beeping sounds, and those men with mustaches because mustaches were in back in the 80s, right?
[01:02]
Rana Kordahi
And my father must have angered a man into road rage. This man suddenly appeared at the window of my father's car and aimed a rifle straight at my father's head. But this time my father remained calm under pressure. He built rapport, he negotiated, and in just a few minutes my father had sold the man out of pulling the trigger. My stories may be a little extreme, maybe dramatic -- and to be honest I wasn't going to share them, I was kind of hesitant. But then I thought back: most things in my life, whether they were life and death or whether they were subtle, depended on the art of selling and negotiation. Because they could not only save your life but the life of those that you loved. And also, knowing how to sell can help you get ahead in life.
[02:01]
Rana Kordahi
I personally love the word "sales" and I don't try and sugarcoat it for anything that it's not. Now when people hear this word, "sales," they feel a bit uncomfortable. This word is a little bit taboo. But we have to accept and embrace that we are all salespeople, whether we like it or not -- whether you are selling yourself on a first date, whether you are selling yourself at a job interview, whether you want to start a business and need to know how to sell, or whether you want to be the person that you want to be in life. So we must first embrace that, or be the person in the corner of the room watching everybody with envy getting ahead. Because I'm going to be blunt right here, right now: it doesn't matter how talented you are, how smart, how PhD'd up you are, or technically brilliant you are -- if you don't know how to sell and communicate, you're not going to get very far in life.
[03:00]
Rana Kordahi
I want to establish the two types of salespeople out there. [Refers to a film clip] This film has ruined it for a lot of salespeople. This is not the true portrayal of what happens in the business-to-business world, where trust and relationships are the foundations of closing high-value sales. If any salesperson pulled off those stunts in that film, they'd be out the door in less than a week. Now I want to talk to you about the two types of salespeople. You've got the pushy salesperson and you've got the consultative salesperson. The pushy salesperson has an acronym: ABC -- Always Be Closing. The consultative salesperson has the same acronym, ABC -- but it means something totally different: Always Be Connecting.
[04:02]
Rana Kordahi
Pushy salesperson -- they talk a lot, they don't listen to what you have to say, and they push their products and services on to you within seconds of meeting you. The consultative salesperson listens and finds out how they can solve your most important problems and change your life. Pushy salesperson: they walk into a networking situation and think, "I wonder who I can take from here today." Consultative salesperson: they walk into a networking situation and think, "I wonder who I can help here today." Now that I've established the two types of salespeople and the difference between them, and why knowing how to sell is important, I want to share with you how knowing how to sell has changed my life and how it could help you be the person that you want to be.
[05:00]
Rana Kordahi
First of all, it has helped me become a more confident person. I learned pretty quickly that it didn't matter how well I knew my pitch or how well I knew my products and services -- if I did not know how to sell with confidence and be a confident person, I was not going to get very far. Now how did I learn this? It was through one particular experience in Mexico years ago. I worked selling timeshares in Mexico, and to get a job at this resort you had to know how to speak English and you had to know how to sell. There were two sales reps in particular -- one was called James and the other was called Santiago. James was English, had a great accent, was tall, handsome, dressed in three- and four-piece suits, had a PhD, knew his pitch inside out, and was well-spoken. This guy was pretty smart.
[06:02]
Rana Kordahi
Now Santiago, on the other hand -- his English was not great, he had a heavy accent, he was a high school dropout, he didn't dress well, he was a bit short and stocky, and he did not know much about anything. Now, who do you think was the top salesperson out of these two? Santiago. Correct. And some people were surprised -- how is Santiago selling? Compared to James he didn't have a chance. And I did wonder. I had the privilege of shadowing both these guys and befriending them. Santiago's secret was that he had unshakable, soft confidence in himself and in his abilities. No matter how many no's he heard, no matter how many failures he faced, it did not falter his self-confidence.
[07:05]
Rana Kordahi
Knowing how to sell has helped me build rapport with just about anybody. "People buy people" -- this was one of the first phrases I learned in one of my very first sales jobs. The trainer, Doug, wrote this phrase on the board and said, "People buy into you before they're going to buy your products and services. So if they don't like and trust you, you can be sure they're not really going to buy -- unless they're dying in a hospital bed and you're the doctor that they don't like." So at the end of the day we have to start with building rapport and trust with people. Most of us know that building rapport has to do with a genuine smile, open body language, taking an interest in the other person, even mirroring and matching, the firm handshake, eye contact -- all that stuff. But I want to take the concept of rapport further. I want to take it into the online digital world where we spend a lot of our time.
[08:01]
Rana Kordahi
How many times have you scrolled your Facebook, Instagram, or LinkedIn feed and made mental notes about people -- whether they're your friends, family, or strangers? "Oh, I like him -- he's so inspiring." "Oh Jesus, this woman is so negative, I need to block her." This happens all the time. So we are building virtual rapport with people online, and people are building rapport and connection with us when they don't even know us. I had to learn this the hard way. About six years ago I became a vegan and I wanted to spread the vegan message. The best way to do that, obviously, was on Facebook. So I started spreading my vegan message in a quite aggressive, angry way -- and no one was listening. One day I thought, "What's going on? No one cares about animals." I was feeling sorry for myself. Then I remembered the phrase I learned so many years ago: "People buy people."
[09:03]
Rana Kordahi
I thought, of course -- I've been applying this to my sales life and coaching this to many salespeople. Once I applied this concept of "people buy people" to my animal advocacy, I saw a tremendous change. People started messaging me saying, "I want to go vegan," or telling me they had been inspired by my posts. So no matter what you want to sell -- whether it's your products, services, philosophy, ideology, or political beliefs -- always think: "Do people like me and trust me before they are open to my message?" Knowing how to sell has helped me persuade and influence. Now, persuasion and influence can have a bad connotation. To be honest with you, it is not a magic wand. Nobody is going to be persuaded and influenced by anything if they don't want to buy it. People need autonomy in their decision-making -- studies show that -- and we cannot trigger their fight-or-flight response. The more we push, the more we trigger that. But we can do something different instead.
[10:02]
Rana Kordahi
Studies show that by asking smart questions and getting somebody to think for themselves, we are more likely to be able to influence their decision. There are three things I want you to remember before going out into any sales interaction -- whether you're selling your products, services, or ideas. Number one: people are more likely to buy when they are talking than when you are talking. Number two: people are more likely to buy when it's their idea than when it's your idea. And number three: you should never begin by pitching, selling, preaching, or providing solutions before the person you're dealing with has articulated what they want to gain or achieve.
[11:00]
Rana Kordahi
Why is this? Sales takes a lot of concepts from psychology and understands human behavior. Studies show that when we ask questions, people are more likely to be open. Let me give you an example. Say I went to see a psychologist and said, "My husband is an abusive alcoholic and I don't know what to do." The psychologist is not going to say, "You need to leave that jerk before he kills you." Instead, the psychologist is going to ask questions so the decision becomes my own. They'll ask: "So, what would you like to change most about your current situation?" And I'll start thinking. Then they might ask: "Based on the challenges you're having in your relationship, how has this been affecting your life?" And then: "What solutions or actions do you think you might need to take?" -- in order for me to be driven to take action, rather than being told what to do.
[12:01]
Rana Kordahi
Now I want to take the same concept and apply it to a product. Say I'm trying to sell you a printer and your printer is not working. I'm not going to tell you how brilliant my printer is -- because you're not going to listen. I'm going to say: "So, tell me about your current printer. What would you like to change most about it?" Then: "Based on what you've told me about the problems you're having, how is this printer affecting your work productivity?" And so on. Always think about getting people to think and believe that something is their idea rather than you pushing something onto them. That's how we persuade and influence.
[13:01]
Rana Kordahi
Knowing how to sell has helped me learn how to communicate to people's values -- not my own. Many times when we are communicating to people, we speak in the values that resonate with us, not with them. How many times have you tried to convince your child, your spouse, or your colleagues based on your own interests and what you value most? I was coaching a travel agent named Maggie. She told me a story about how she was trying to sell a vacation to a guy called Tony. What was important for Maggie on her vacations? Relaxing at a nice beach, sunbathing, cocktails, restaurant food, and Wi-Fi. Tony, on the other hand, was very different. He was an introvert who wanted a modern suite, a kitchen to cook his bodybuilding food, a gym at the hotel, and very fast Wi-Fi because he was an entrepreneur. When Maggie tried to sell this vacation, she was talking based on her interests -- and she lost Tony within minutes.
[14:03]
Rana Kordahi
So think about when you are trying to convince somebody -- whether it's your child, your spouse, your colleague, or your client -- are you talking in a language that resonates with you or with them? To understand their language, we need to do a discovery and ask smart questions. Finally, I want to leave you with a story that helped me tremendously become the person I am today and led me onto my personal development journey. It started with a sales role where I was not selling and was quite frustrated. I was reading every book on sales. One day I was sitting in the staff room reading about how to overcome objections, and a sales mentor saw me. He said, "I want you to throw this book away. Your only objection is your mindset. I want you to try something different."
[15:00]
Rana Kordahi
He said, "Close your eyes, and I want you to visualize and feel that you are with your customer right now and that you are building amazing rapport. Close your eyes and feel and believe that you are helping them by asking great questions, and they are telling you all of their issues. Visualize and feel that you are going to change their life with this product that you're selling. Visualize and feel that they are so open that they are signing the contract and they're so happy. And visualize and feel the number that you're going to sell. Now open your eyes and write down the number that you're going to sell."
[16:01]
Rana Kordahi
When he first told me this, I -- a very logical person -- thought, "What is this hocus-pocus magic? This is not going to work." Then I thought, "You know what, I've got nothing to lose. Let me try it." So I did. And within not even a week I started selling. I started doing this every day religiously. Then I thought: imagine what this could do to my personal life. So I started applying it to my health, my fitness, making money, my business, going on dates -- and then I took it further and started applying it to my morning meditation. I've been in sales for 20 years, and there are three things that I've learned you need to have to be successful in sales or in business. Number one: courage. Courage is about going out there, understanding that yes, you are going to get rejected, and it's okay -- and just keep on doing it. Number two: patience. Plant seeds today, they'll grow tomorrow. But many people plant seeds, stop being patient, and give up. And the last thing: you have to have a relentless work ethic. There is no such thing as overnight success. I've paid a lot of money for overnight success courses and they are all BS. You need to work really hard and it is going to take time. Thank you for your time. Go out and sell.
AI Master Prompt

The AI prompt on this page is auto-generated from the transcript content and is intended to support further exploration of the topics, concepts, and conclusions discussed. It is provided for informational purposes only. The user is solely responsible for all outcomes resulting from its use.

Master Prompt — Rana Kordahi: How to Achieve Anything by Learning to Sell
You are helping me explore and apply the ideas from Rana Kordahi's TEDxCQU talk: "How to Achieve Anything in Life by Learning How to Sell." Here is a summary of the core framework and principles.

CONTEXT

Kordahi argues that selling is not a profession -- it is a fundamental human skill that shapes outcomes in every area of life. Whether you are interviewing for a job, advocating for a cause, negotiating a conflict, raising a child, or trying to be the person you want to be, you are selling. The question is not whether you sell, but whether you do it well or poorly.

She draws a sharp line between two types of salespeople. The pushy salesperson leads with product, pushes hard, talks more than they listen, and frames every interaction as something to extract from. The consultative salesperson leads with curiosity, asks questions first, listens carefully, and thinks about what they can give -- not what they can take. The consultative model produces better results and better relationships.

The talk draws heavily on behavioral psychology. People need autonomy in their decisions. Pushing triggers the fight-or-flight response and closes people down. Asking smart questions -- and letting people reach their own conclusions -- is the mechanism of genuine influence. This is the same technique used in good psychotherapy: you do not tell someone what to do, you ask the right questions so they figure it out themselves.

A key story contrasts two salespeople at a Mexican timeshare resort: James, highly educated, well-spoken, well-dressed, with deep product knowledge -- and Santiago, a high school dropout with poor English and unremarkable presentation. Santiago outsold James consistently because he had unshakable confidence under rejection. Credentials and polish are not the limiting factor. Self-belief that survives no after no is.

Kordahi also describes how a mentor's visualization practice -- seeing yourself building rapport, asking good questions, closing the deal, before you walk in -- shifted her from struggling to selling within a week. She extended the practice to health, relationships, and business. The core point: mindset is not the soft variable; it is often the primary one.

KEY PRINCIPLES

- Selling is a universal life skill. Everyone is already doing it; most people are not doing it deliberately or well.
- The consultative approach -- curiosity, questions, connection -- outperforms the pushy approach in both the short and long run.
- People buy people before they buy products or ideas. Rapport, including online/digital rapport, is the foundation of every persuasive interaction.
- The three rules of persuasion: people move more when they are talking, more when the idea feels like their own, and not at all until they have articulated what they want or need.
- Communicate to the other person's values, not yours. Discovery questions reveal what actually matters to them.
- Confidence that survives rejection is rarer and more valuable than credentials or craft.
- Visualization is a practical performance tool, not mysticism.
- The three pillars of sustained success: courage (act despite rejection), patience (compound effort over time), and relentless work ethic (there are no shortcuts).

WHAT THIS IS NOT

This is not a framework for manipulation, deception, or high-pressure tactics. Kordahi explicitly rejects the pushy model. Influence here means helping someone reach their own decision through better questions -- not engineering an outcome they would reject if they thought it through. It is also not a shortcut framework. The three pillars -- courage, patience, work ethic -- are a direct refutation of anyone promising fast results with low effort.

HOW TO USE THIS CHAT

1. CLARIFY -- If I describe a situation where I am trying to persuade, influence, or communicate, help me identify which principles from this framework apply and where I might be making the common mistakes (pitching too early, speaking to my own values, not asking enough questions).

2. APPLY -- Help me build out specific questions I could ask in a real conversation using the discovery model Kordahi describes. I will describe the situation and the person; you help me develop the question sequence.

3. PRACTICE -- Role-play the consultative approach with me. You play the other person; I practice leading with questions rather than pitching or prescribing.

4. AUDIT -- If I share something I wrote or said in an attempt to persuade someone, audit it against the framework. Where did I push rather than ask? Where did I speak to my own values instead of theirs? Where did I pitch before discovery?

5. EXTEND -- Help me apply these principles beyond commercial sales: to advocacy, management, parenting, negotiation, online presence, or any persuasive context I name.

6. CHALLENGE -- If I slip into the pushy model (leading with my opinion, prescribing before asking, trying to win rather than understand), call it out and redirect me.

Respond in a grounded, direct, no-nonsense tone. No cheerleading. Help me recognize what I am actually doing -- not just what I think I am doing.

To begin: tell me one specific situation in your life right now where you are trying to influence, persuade, or change someone's mind -- and I will ask you one question about it before we go further.